QUOTE(simplydivine9 @ Dec 10 2008, 08:58 PM)

Good comparison. And off topic a bit: I wonder if Julia Roberts is the last of a dying breed. I know some people can't stand her, but you've gotta admit (before she went into semi-retirement to raise her kids) she's a rarity among actresses in that she can open a movie all on her own and do comedy and drama equally well. There are plenty of actresses who are arguably better -- like Cate Blanchett and Marisa Tomei and Nicole Kidman -- but for some reason they don't have the charisma Julia has and it doesn't translate into ticket sales. I guess Hollywood is pinning their hopes on Reese Witherspoon (and perhaps later down the line Ellen Page).
I've always loved Julia Roberts because there is something about her that is so warm, welcoming and friendly, and she does have the talent to play a broad spectrum of characters. But as you said, there are better actresses out there but they don't attract audiences for some reason. I think with Kidman (one of the most overrated actresses ever) she comes off as very cold and distant, and not only that but she comes off as someone who is stuck-up, full of herself and looks down her nose at people, which isn't an endearing quality.
As for Reese Whiterspoon, I like her and think she has talent, but she has yet to really capture me with an impressive performance. Yes, she won an Oscar for Walk The Line but that doesn't mean she's a great actress. I mean, look at some recent winners of an Academy Award who have done nothing really good since they won: Cuba Gooding Jr., Mira Sorvino, Halle Berry, Roberto Benigni, Adrien Brody, Helen Hunt, etc.
I think Ellen Page may be the actress Hollywood can bet on because she's done some really solid work in her very brief career so far. I remember seeing her in Hard Candy and The Tracey Fragments and was quite impressed, and she was even good in smaller roles in Marion Bridge and Wilby Wonderful. The only thing she needs to avoid is getting typecast as the angst ridden teen. But from what I've seen of her abilities, I think she can manage to be very sucessful in mainstream movies and yet still have her foot in smaller indie flicks.